A Mystery Guest Sparks Romance Rumors
On the March 27, 2025 episode of Watch What Happens Live, Southern Charm star Craig Conover dropped a hint that set social media abuzz. Admitting with a coy grin that he's indeed "dating someone new," Craig left fans guessing, carefully withholding the identity of his newfound romantic interest.
But observant viewers couldn't help but notice a familiar face in the studio audience—none other than Natalie Buffett herself, the popular influencer and former flame of NFL star Dak Prescott and MLB player Jack Flaherty. Her unexpected presence immediately sparked a flurry of excitement online, with speculation mounting about whether she was the woman behind Craig's mysterious remark.
Anonymous Tip-Offs and Social Media Clues
Fueling the flames further, celebrity gossip platform Deux Moi soon received an anonymous tip naming Natalie as Craig's secret love interest, labeling the intel as "confirmed." Adding to the intrigue, eagle-eyed fans found digital breadcrumbs scattered across social media accounts, noticing that both Craig Conover and reality star Shannon Beador recently started following Buffett's Instagram profile and interacting with her posts.
With over 76,000 followers and an influential role as Director of Content Creation at OxeFit, the certified yoga instructor has maintained an impressive public presence. Her frequent updates showcase an active, vibrant lifestyle, making her a perfect match for reality fame and spotlight romance.
From Charleston Streets to Spotlight Seats
While neither Craig nor Natalie has directly confirmed their budding love, Natalie's visit to Charleston—Craig Conover’s hometown—added another compelling chapter to this engaging drama. All this unfolds amid fresh memories of Craig’s recent split from his former long-term girlfriend Paige DeSorbo, leading fans to wonder if he's found new happiness in Natalie Buffett’s charming company.
As reality TV devotees eagerly await further confirmation, one thing is certain: this unfolding romance has all the elements of an engaging storyline—anonymous whispers, romantic connections, social media sleuthing, and a sprinkle of celebrity glamour. Only time will reveal how this tale truly ends.
